The real problem with most brand strategies
Most brand strategies aren’t failing because they are bad ideas; they are failing because they never make it off the PowerPoint slide. Is your brand building awareness, or is it truly engineering market preference?
Harvard Business Review reported a 2016 estimate that 67% of well-formulated strategies fail due to poor execution1. Even then, most companies’ strategies deliver only 63% of the financial value they promise2.
I see this constantly in the GCC and MEA markets. Companies spend months and millions developing a “brand strategy”, only to watch it stall when it hits the commercial reality of the market. Here is the real problem with most brand strategies, and how to fix it.
1. The execution gap is the real killer
Many brand strategies falter not because of inherent flaws in the strategy itself, but due to a massive gap in execution. This arises from a lack of alignment across vision, incentives, leadership focus and resources.
When the strategic vision fails to permeate all levels of the organisation, employees are unclear about how their daily work contributes to the overall goal. Operational fragmentation sets in: existing processes, tools and information flows are not adapted to support the new strategy, creating internal friction.
2. Confusing identity with preference
A critical misunderstanding exists between brand identity and brand preference.
Brand identity focuses on how a company presents itself: its logo, its colour palette, its stated values. But true market success hinges on cultivating brand preference. Preference is engineered; it is the set of conditions under which customers consistently choose your brand over competitors because you are the easiest, safest and most valuable choice.
Kmart is a classic example of an identity crisis. Their lack of a clear, focused vision and generic brand positioning led to a steady decline, as they failed to differentiate themselves from competitors like Walmart and Target, who had engineered clear market preference3.
3. Positioning defines, messaging amplifies
There is often deep confusion between brand positioning and messaging.
Positioning is the strategic decision of how a brand is perceived relative to competitors in the market. Messaging is the tactical communication used to articulate and amplify that chosen position. When companies confuse the two, they end up with marketing campaigns that sound nice but fail to stake out a defensible commercial territory.
4. The trap of awareness without conversion
Many brand strategies prioritise generating broad awareness, but fail to engineer the conditions that drive conversion. This results in brands that are recognised but not consistently chosen.
Relying on vanity metrics or lagging indicators that do not directly measure progress towards strategic objectives leads to a false sense of accomplishment. If your strategy generates “buzz” but does not increase category share or revenue, it is a failed strategy.
The winning framework: operational alignment
Brands that win consistently embed performance tracking into their operational fabric. They build robust operating models that translate strategic intent into operational reality.
- Strategic clarity: define a clear, concise vision and ruthlessly prioritise three to five strategic initiatives.
- Preference-driven positioning: engineer market preference by clearly defining your unique value proposition.
- Integrated accountability: foster a culture of transparency and ownership, where accountability is non-negotiable and performance is tied to strategic outcomes.
Sources
- Ron Carucci, “Executives Fail to Execute Strategy Because They’re Too Internally Focused,” Harvard Business Review, 13 November 2017. hbr.org
- Michael C. Mankins and Richard Steele, “Turning Great Strategy into Great Performance,” Harvard Business Review, July 2005. Summary on bain.com
- Knowledge at Wharton, “Kmart’s 20-Year Identity Crisis,” 30 January 2002. knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu